CFD Simulation of complex rotor equipment using FloEFD – Part I: LEGO Technic Aero Hawk

...Published 2016-08-30

Ever wondered if that LEGO Aero Hawk Helicopter from your childhood could actually fly?


Figure 1: LEGO Technic Aero Hawk. The CAD model of the Aero Hawk was obtained from

So, you find yourself one day just surfing the web and suddenly you stumble upon that LEGO Technics Aero Hawk model from your seventh birthday, and immediately you think “Hmmm, I wonder if it could actually fly”.  Granted in the imagination of a seven-year-old anything is possible and this particular Aero Hawk was capable of doing loops, flying upside down even reaching warp speed (All of this even with Homer Simpson at the helm).  But you’re all grown-up now and you’ve probably lost all of that wild imagination of youth due to a combination of the harshness of reality and a degree in engineering that taught you that anything is indeed possible, but sadly everything isn’t.  Therefore you set out to apply your engineering knowledge to determine if there is even the slightest possibility of this Aero Hawk managing some form of flight.  You dive into your vast engineering toolbox and pull out your traditional Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) tool.

At first glance, you recognise that the geometry is quite complex.  The LEGO parts being modelled in meticulous detail, which the designer in you can definitely appreciate, but knowing what you know about CFD simulation, immediately you start to think “How on earth am I going to build the mesh for this model”?  You consider doing some serious CAD clean-up to reduce the complexity but consequently realise that you would lose too much of the authenticity of the LEGO model when simplifying the geometry down to the level typically required to perform CFD simulation with.  You are faced with a conundrum.  The seven-year-old in you demands that the model remain as realistic as possible.  The thirty-something-year-old analyst in you cannot begin to imagine how hard it is going to be to perform such a CFD simulation.  It is time to revive and even stretch a little further that imagination that is long lost due to the doctrine of what is and what isn’t possible in the world of CFD… Imagine a world in which one can open up a CAD model, specify the mesh settings, apply boundary conditions and start solving within a matter of minutes.  Sounds like a bit of a stretch of the imagination, doesn’t it? Enter FloEFD!

You pull out the ol’ credit card and get yourself a copy of FloEFD® as integrated in Siemens NX® to analyse the LEGO Aero Hawk helicopter.  You make use of the new Sliding Mesh technology in FloEFD to simulate the rotation of the main rotor.  This serves as a good test to see how FloEFD would handle the rotation of more complex geometry.  You load the model into NX as-is, with only an additional rotating region part (simple cylindrical component) modeled to represent the rotation region that encapsulates the main rotor. You apply a rotor speed of 300RPM.  You set the computational domain size and make use of a relatively coarse base mesh as a start with local mesh refinements to control the level of mesh resolution in the rotating region and on the helicopter.  You are satisfied with the resulting mesh resolution as in the image below, with approximately 1million cells being generated.  You are completely amazed at the fact that FloEFD had no trouble creating the mesh even with all of the small geometric features and unnecessary narrow channels between the stacked LEGO blocks.  This is obviously wasteful and one would necessarily spend some time cleaning up the CAD model in this regard.  Nonetheless, you are curious as to how FloEFD will cope with this and you proceed, leaving the model as-is in order to test the solver stability.  When you are ready to solve you notice that you have access to all of your CPU cores, you are very appreciative that you did not have to pay extra for this very useful capability. You select all 16 cores to your availability (or 4 if you don’t have that luxury) and press the “Solve” button and leave the simulation to run overnight. The sliding rotation option requires a transient analysis to be conducted and of course you do have to sleep at some point…


Figure 2: FloEFD Immersed Boundary Cartesian Mesh Cut-plot showing Level of Refinement

After catching up on a few Z’s, you see the simulation had finished solving without error or divergence.  Again you find yourself quite impressed.  You play around with the animations post-processing feature and record videos of the velocity field in the plane of the propeller rotation as shown below, the first of which shows the rotation of the mesh within the rotating region just moments after the initial start-up. The second animation shows the velocity field as developed after a few rotations. You make cut-plots of the velocity over the propeller blades and you note in these images the development of the boundary layer at the propeller surfaces, one of the key technologies within FloEFD that make it possible to perform simulations with such complex geometry. You continue to be impressed even further and you start imagining what else you would be able to do with such a unique analysis tool.


Figure 3: FloEFD Sliding Mesh Rotation


Figure 4: Velocity contour plot with rotor blade rotation

FloEFD Sliding Mesh Rotation: Velocity Contour Plots

Figure 5: Velocity Cut-plots around rotor blade detail

Now that you’re are extremely happy that there is at least a tool that makes these kind of analyses possible, the question remains to be answered – Can this LEGO Aero Hawk actually fly, or will it forever be confined to realm of imagination?  You make a time-history plot of the propeller lift force.  After close inspection you can see a definite positive offset in the average lift force, albeit fairly small, definitely not enough to lift the helicopter off the ground in the real world, but still a positive lift force nonetheless, enough to revive that youthful imagination that knows no bounds.  You start to think like the seven-year-old you once were, thinking “if I can develop a strong lightweight material, lighter than anything known to man…or if I can spin the propeller at 3,000,000 RPM…or if Homer would just lose a few pounds (granted that would require quite a leap in imagination), then this LEGO Aero Hawk from my childhood just might actually be able to fly”!  Thanks to FloEFD this whole new world of CFD has been unlocked.  A world not confined to simplified geometry or constrained by meshes and convergence issues.  What seemed hard to imagine in the past has become a reality, giving the engineer in you free reign to imagine more…(It goes without saying that the very low lift force is due to the fact that the LEGO propeller does not represent an airfoil very closely.)


Figure 6: Time-history graph of rotor blade lift force

FloEFD (Engineering Fluid Dynamics) is a highly sophisticated CFD tool aimed at Engineers.  The main objective of FloEFD is to enable engineers to make design decisions as quick and simple as possible, without having to ask the resident CFD specialist (if one should be so lucky to employ one of these very rare specimens) to perform the thermal-fluid analyses that traditionally required a lot of expertise and patience.  FloEFD transcends almost all of the inherent obstacles of traditional CFD through innovative and ingenious technologies that truly stretch the imagination.  Some of these technologies include,

  • CAD Embedded
  • Immersed Boundary Adaptive Cartesian Mesh
  • 2-scale Modified Wall Functions
  • Enhanced k-ε Turbulence Model.

These technologies are what make FloEFD the efficient and productive engineering tool that it is.  Now hopefully the engineer in you is starting to imagine again a world of possibilities that seemed lost in translation and that it is easy to imagine a CFD tool that is easy to use, makes meshing a breeze, is highly tolerant of complex geometry and provides quick, stable, accurate and converged solutions.  So in closing, if I may borrow the theme song from The LEGO Movie…LEGO_FloEFD_Themseong
This blog article is Part I of a series of blog articles relating to complex rotor equipment.
Part I: LEGO Technic Aero Hawk
Part II: Apache Helicopter
Part III: Rotating Radar Dish
Part IV: KJ-66 Micro Gas Turbine Thrust Prediction
Part V: Diffusor Shock Waves in a Centrifugal Compressor

Leave a Reply